At each meeting, we taste and grade 3 whiskeys, collect scores, and record an average score into our master tasting log. Our scoring is not an exact science - taste and experience changes over time (hopefully for the better), and our "testing group" varies each meeting. Nevertheless, we find it quite fun and hope this information can help you during your next shopping trip!
High Flight's TOP 10 Whiskeys
#1 - Old Swagger Bottled-In-Bond 12 year
HF Score 3.98 / 100 Proof / $175
#2 - Colonel E.H. Taylor Small Batch
HF Score 3.87 / 100 Proof / $130
#3 - Woodford Double Oaked
HF Score 3.8 / 90.4 Proof / $65
#4 - Penelope Estate 10-year Single Barrel
HF Score 3.7 / 98 Proof / $120
#5 - Pinhook 9 Vertical Series Single Barrel
HF Score 3.69 / 112 Proof / $95
#6 - Wild Turkey 12 (Japanese Edition)
HF Score 3.68 / 101 Proof / $140
#7 - Van Winkle 12-Year
HF Score 3.66 / 90.4 Proof / $150
#8 - Green River Full Proof
HF Score 3.64 / 117 Proof / $55
#9 - Old Forester 1924
HF Score 3.63 / 100 Proof / $125
#10 - Knob Creek 15
HF Score 3.62 / 100 Proof / $100